Fresh Daily · Palmyra, VA

Start your morning with a bagel that was made just for you

Hand-kneaded, boiled, and baked in small batches every morning. Nothing industrial. Nothing stale. Just honest bread, the way it should be.

Order by Phone Explore Our Menu

Scroll

Our Story

Baked with patience,
served with warmth

Bagelicious began with a simple conviction: a bagel should taste like bread. Not like a package. Not like something that sat on a shelf. Real flour, real water, real time.

Every morning, our ovens fire up before sunrise. Each bagel is hand-rolled, briefly boiled, then baked until the crust sings. We keep our lineup small so nothing ever feels rushed — and that's exactly why our regulars keep coming back.

Daily

Fresh Bakes

12+

Varieties

Local

Community

What We Make

From our oven to your plate

Every bagel starts as a ball of dough and ends as something worth waiting for. Here are some of our most loved varieties.

Classic

Plain

The benchmark. Chewy interior, crisp crust, a whisper of malt. Perfect with butter or cream cheese.

Best Seller

Everything

Sesame, poppy, garlic, onion — our everything blend coats each bagel in flavor with every bite.

Hearty

Whole Wheat

Stone-ground flour gives this one a deeper color and a nutty sweetness that stands on its own.

Sweet

Blueberry

Real blueberries folded into the dough. Tart, juicy, and naturally sweet — no added sugar needed.

Sweet

Cinnamon Raisin

Warm cinnamon swirled through plump raisins. Feels like breakfast dessert before lunch even arrives.

Savory

Garlic Herb

Roasted garlic and a garden of herbs baked into every bite. Ideal for sandwiches or on its own.

How It Works

From dough to door

There's no shortcut to a great bagel. Here's what happens behind our counter every single morning.

Mix & Rest

High-protein flour, filtered water, sea salt, and a touch of malt. The dough rests slowly so flavors develop naturally.

Knead & Shape

Every bagel is rolled by hand. No machines pushing through the same mold — each one gets its own attention.

Boil & Bake

A brief boil sets the crust, then into the oven where the heat turns it golden and chewy. This is the magic step.

Fresh to You

Warm from the oven, ready for your order. Whether you pick it up or we deliver, it's still perfect.

What People Say

Loved by our neighbors

We don't need a big marketing budget. Our regulars do the talking for us.

"I drove past three grocery stores on the way here. Nothing compares to a Bagelicious everything bagel — warm, chewy, and loaded with flavor. It's worth the detour."

Margaret K.

Palmyra, VA

"We order a mixed dozen every Sunday for the week ahead. The blueberry and cinnamon raisin are gone first — but the plain never lasts either. Solid, consistent, and always fresh."

James R.

Lynchburg, VA

"As someone who's picky about bread, I can tell these are made the right way. You can taste the patience in every bite. The garlic herb is my new favorite — absolutely incredible."

Sarah A.

Palmyra, VA

Get in Touch

We'd love to hear from you

Visit Us

Address

265 Turkeysag Trl, Palmyra 22963

Phone

(434) 589-0915

hello@bagelicious.com

Opening Hours

Monday – Friday 6:00 AM – 3:00 PM

Saturday 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM

Sunday Closed

Send Us a Message

Message Sent!

Thanks for reaching out. We'll get back to you within 24 hours.